CD Import

[USED:Cond.AB] Sym, 8, 9, : Mackerras / Scottish Co

Schubert (1797-1828)

User Review :5.0
(2)

Used Details

Artwork
Here *The artwork is of the new items and may differ from the actual item.
Other Condition
:
Non
:
HMV record shop online

Item Details

Genre
Catalogue Number
CD80502
Label
Format
CD
Other
:
Import

Product Description

(This HMV Review is for new items and is only for reference. Novelty will NOT be available for used items despite mentioned bellow.)

Franz Schubert's Symphony No. 9, "The Great," was completed in the year that the composer died. Conceived on the grandest scale, this is not a symphony of defeat, but a powerful call to life. He was still a young man, and the lyricism and vitality of this music reflect this. Every movement contains a heartbeat-like pulse, dotted rhythms that propel the music forward.
This recording adds some fresh air to the current discography of Schubert symphonies. Charles Mackerras uses the exact number of strings that Schubert had available to him at the time, and also uses period instruments such as natural horn and natural trombone. The result is a salon atmosphere rarely heard in this symphony. While the articulation and rhythm sometimes lag, the sweetness of tone and flexibility of line make the work much more alive. Some new tempi--such as a faster opening andante--keep it from being ponderous.
The stormy and atmospheric "Unfinished" Symphony is also included on this disc. The downsized Scottish Chamber Orchestra gives an intimate performance that, in the maggiore sections, bubbles into the world of extroversion. This symphony is a simpler work, and the ensemble does well to let it speak for itself.

Customer Reviews

Comprehensive Evaluation

★
★
★
★
★

5.0

★
★
★
★
★
 
2
★
★
★
★
☆
 
0
★
★
★
☆
☆
 
0
★
★
☆
☆
☆
 
0
★
☆
☆
☆
☆
 
0
★
★
★
★
★
強すぎないが、明確でゆるぎない光と知性に...

投稿日:2012/04/06 (金)

強すぎないが、明確でゆるぎない光と知性に彩られた、美しい演奏です。シューベルトの歌謡性と音の運動性を両立し、起伏をたどる間に渦の中にまきこまれているのを感じます。特にグレートの後に未完成を持ってくる作曲年代順の曲順によって、未完成の未完成である必然が始めて理解できた気がしました。単体の交響曲としてはこれ以上の演奏はあるかもしれませんが、この配列によってシューベルトの巨大で圧倒的なものへの憧れから、終息への美学への軌跡を感じさせてくれるという意味で最良の演奏と思いました。

harekazuya さん | 東京都 | 不明

1
★
★
★
★
★
これは意外な掘り出し物。かなりレパートリ...

投稿日:2006/03/20 (月)

これは意外な掘り出し物。かなりレパートリーの広いマッケラスだが、このグレートは何度聴いても飽きない新鮮さに満ちている。入手できるほぼすべてのマッケラスのCDを聞いたが、その中でも3本の指に入ると思う。

インディ/作響 さん | 東京 | 不明

2

Recommend Items